Partial vs Full Pool Removal: Which One Do You Need?
- Partial removal (also called fill-in or abandonment): drainage holes in the floor, the top of the walls taken down, the pool filled and compacted. Lower cost. The area is for landscaping.
- Full removal: the whole shell comes out and the hole is filled with compacted soil. With an engineer's compaction report, the area can be built on.
- Our recent written estimates: partial $10,500 to $11,500, full $18,000 to $21,500, permit included.
- Choose by what you want on that spot in the next 5 to 10 years, not by today's price alone.
Partial and full pool removal side by side
| Partial removal | Full removal | |
|---|---|---|
| What comes out | Top of the walls and pool equipment; the shell stays | The whole shell, walls, floor and usually the deck |
| Drainage | Holes broken in the floor so water drains | Not needed, the shell is gone |
| Fill | Clean soil, compacted | Clean soil compacted in layers, often tested by an engineer |
| Can you build there later? | No, landscaping only (in the cities we have checked) | Only with engineered fill and the engineer's compaction report |
| Recent Bay Demo price | $10,500 to $11,500 | $18,000 to $19,000 without an engineer; $19,000 to $21,500 with engineered fill (buildable) |
| Best for | Lawn, garden, turf; keeping cost down | ADU, addition, patio slab; selling to a buyer who may build |
How Bay Demo does a partial removal
- Permit. We apply with your city and include it in the price.
- Drain and disconnect. The pool is drained the way your city allows, and the pump, filter and heater come out.
- Drainage holes. We break three holes, each about 3 ft wide, in the pool floor so water can drain out of the old shell.
- Walls down. The walls are taken down 2 ft below grade.
- Fill and compact. Clean soil goes in and is compacted.
- Final inspection. We stay until the city signs off.
Some cities set their own numbers. Pleasanton asks for an opening of at least 24 inches at the lowest point and the whole bond beam removed. Cupertino asks for at least three 12-inch holes, 8 inches of compacted gravel and filter fabric. We follow whatever your city requires.
Source: City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site) · City of Cupertino: Swimming Pool Removal Requirements (PDF, 3/2024) (opens the official site)
What full removal and engineered fill mean
In a full removal the shell, walls and floor are broken out and hauled away, and the hole is filled with clean soil in compacted layers. When the area must be buildable, a geotechnical or civil engineer tests the fill and signs a compaction report for the final inspection. That is what "engineered fill" means.
Pleasanton calls this Option 2: fill in 6 to 12 inch lifts compacted to 90% (ASTM D1557), with a compaction report at the final. Cupertino calls it Option B: fill certified by a licensed engineer, with a report stating the area is suitable for future construction.
Source: City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site) · City of Cupertino: Swimming Pool Removal Requirements (PDF, 3/2024) (opens the official site)
How to choose
- You want lawn, garden or turf and plan to stay. Partial removal is usually enough.
- You may build an ADU, an addition or a slab. Full removal with engineered fill. Doing it later costs more than doing it once.
- You may sell in the next few years. Either way, keep the closed permit and the final inspection record. Tell us your plans and we price both.
- Your city only allows one method. Then the choice is made for you. See the rules for your city on our pool removal permits page.
Partial vs full pool removal: common questions
Can you build on a partially removed pool?
Not in the cities we have checked. Pleasanton (Option 1) and Cupertino (Option A) both limit the area to non-structural use. To build, you need a full removal with engineered fill.
Is a partial pool removal permitted?
Yes, in the cities we have checked it is a permitted, inspected method. Pleasanton and Cupertino both list it as an option in their pool removal requirements.
What is engineered fill?
Fill placed in compacted layers and tested by a geotechnical or civil engineer, who signs a compaction report for the final inspection. It is what makes the area buildable.
Can the ground settle after a partial removal?
It can. Cupertino notes that an area filled with the shell left in place may settle, which is one reason it is limited to landscaping. Good drainage holes and compaction reduce the risk.
How much more does a full removal cost?
In our recent written estimates, about $6,500 to $11,000 more than a partial removal for a typical backyard pool, depending on access and whether an engineer is needed.
Keep reading
- Pool removal cost in the Bay Area, with a quick price check
- Bay Area pool removal permits, city by city
- Pool removal in Pleasanton
- Pool removal in Cupertino
- Bay Demo pool removal service
Official sources
- City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site)
- City of Cupertino: Swimming Pool Removal Requirements (PDF, 3/2024) (opens the official site)