Licensed & Insured · CA License #1055298 Permits handled for you 5.0 on Google
Home / Pool Removal / ADU After Pool Removal
California · ADU

Building an ADU Where Your Pool Was: Removal, Fill and State Rules

By Mateus Lima, owner of Bay Demo, CA License #1055298 · Updated

Quick answer
  • An ADU is a building, so the ground under it has to carry one. In Pleasanton, Cupertino and Palo Alto that means a full pool removal with engineered fill and an engineer's report, and Hayward asks for an engineer's geotechnical investigation and report before you build over a removed pool.
  • California ADU law: a detached ADU up to 1,200 sq ft, side and rear setbacks of no more than 4 ft for a new ADU, and local building code rules for detached dwellings still apply.
  • The ADU application is reviewed ministerially: the city must say whether it is complete within 15 business days and decide within 60 days of a complete application when a home already exists on the lot.
  • Our recent written estimates for a full removal with engineered fill: $19,000 to $21,500, permit included.

Why a partial fill-in does not work under an ADU

CityShell left in placeTo build over the old pool
PleasantonOption 1: no compaction test, non-structural use onlyOption 2: full removal, fill compacted to 90%, geotechnical compaction report at the final
CupertinoOption A: landscaping onlyOption B: full removal, fill certified by a licensed engineer
HaywardAllowed with drainage holes, for a yardAn engineer's geotechnical investigation and backfill recommendations, report at the final
Palo AltoNot allowed: complete removal requiredComplete removal, compacted fill and a geotechnical or soils engineer report

California's ADU law does not mention pools or soil. The link is in the law itself: local building code requirements that apply to detached dwellings still apply to an ADU. That is where the city's rules for building over fill come from. In Pleasanton and Cupertino, an old shell left in the ground limits the area to landscaping, and Palo Alto requires complete removal; Hayward asks for an engineer's geotechnical investigation and report before you build over a removed pool.

Source: City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site) · City of Cupertino: Swimming Pool Removal Requirements (PDF, 3/2024) (opens the official site) · City of Hayward: Swimming Pool Removal (PDF, created 7-26-18) (opens the official site) · City of Palo Alto: Inspection Guidelines, Pool & Spa Demolition (PDF, rev. 12/20/2018) (opens the official site) · California Government Code 66314 (ADU size, setbacks, building code) (opens the official site)

What California ADU law sets

RuleWhat the law says
What an ADU isAn attached or detached unit with complete independent living facilities, on a lot with a proposed or existing primary residence (Gov. Code 66313).
Detached sizeTotal floor area of a detached ADU "shall not exceed 1,200 square feet" (Gov. Code 66314).
Attached sizeUp to 50 percent of the existing primary dwelling (Gov. Code 66314).
SetbacksNo more than 4 ft from the side and rear lot lines for a new ADU (Gov. Code 66314).
Floor the city cannot go belowA local maximum cannot be less than 850 sq ft, or 1,000 sq ft for more than one bedroom, and the city must allow at least 800 sq ft with 4 ft side and rear setbacks (Gov. Code 66321).
HeightAt least 16 ft must be allowed for a detached ADU on a lot with an existing or proposed home (Gov. Code 66321).
Ministerial approvalOne detached, new construction ADU with 4 ft side and rear setbacks must be approved ministerially; the city may cap it at 800 sq ft of livable space (Gov. Code 66323, with conditions in the law).

Source: California Government Code 66313 (ADU definitions) (opens the official site) · California Government Code 66314 (ADU size, setbacks, building code) (opens the official site) · California Government Code 66321 (limits on local ADU standards) (opens the official site) · California Government Code 66323 (ADUs approved ministerially) (opens the official site)

How the pool permit and the ADU permit fit together

They are two separate permits. The pool demolition permit covers the removal, the fill and its inspections. The ADU application covers the new building. For the ADU, state law sets the review: the application is approved ministerially, without a hearing; the city must say in writing whether it is complete within 15 business days; and it must approve or deny within 60 days of a complete application when a home already exists on the lot. If it does neither, the application is deemed approved.

Those are the deadlines in the law, not a promise of how long your project takes. The pool removal permit runs on your city's own review time, so we confirm the start date once that permit is approved.

Source: California Government Code 66317 (ADU permit review) (opens the official site)

Planning the removal with the ADU in mind

  1. Place the ADU first. Know where the footprint sits compared with the old pool and the lot lines before the removal is designed.
  2. Choose a full removal. The whole shell comes out, including the floor, and broken concrete is hauled away, not buried.
  3. Engineered fill. Clean fill placed in compacted layers and tested by a geotechnical or civil engineer, who signs the report for the final inspection.
  4. Utilities. The pool's gas, water and electrical are shut off and capped, which also clears the way for the new lines the ADU will need.
  5. Keep the report. Give the compaction report and the final inspection record to your ADU designer.

Our recent written estimates run $19,000 to $21,500 for a full removal with engineered fill, and $18,000 to $19,000 for a full removal without an engineer, permit included.

This is general information, not legal advice; ask an attorney.

Source: City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site) · City of Palo Alto: Inspection Guidelines, Pool & Spa Demolition (PDF, rev. 12/20/2018) (opens the official site)

ADU after pool removal: common questions

Can I build an ADU where my pool was?

Yes, once the ground is ready for it. In Pleasanton, Cupertino and Palo Alto that means a full removal with engineered fill and an engineer's report; Hayward asks for an engineer's geotechnical investigation and report before you build over a removed pool. Check your own city.

How big can a detached ADU be in California?

State law caps a detached ADU at 1,200 sq ft. A city cannot set its maximum below 850 sq ft, or 1,000 sq ft for more than one bedroom, and must ministerially approve one detached ADU of up to 800 sq ft with 4 ft side and rear setbacks.

How close to the property line can an ADU be?

For a new ADU, a city can require no more than 4 ft from the side and rear lot lines (Gov. Code 66314).

How long does the city have to approve an ADU?

Within 60 days of a complete application when a home already exists on the lot, or the application is deemed approved. That deadline is for the ADU; the pool removal permit has its own review.

Do I need an engineer to remove a pool for an ADU?

Yes, in Pleasanton, Cupertino, Palo Alto and Hayward. Building over the old pool requires engineered fill with a geotechnical or civil engineer's report at the final inspection.

Keep reading

Official sources

Mateus Lima, owner of Bay Demo Mateus LimaOwner, Bay Demo · CA Lic. #1055298 5.0 on Google

Step 1 of 2

When do you want to start?
Hi, I'm Mateus. When would you like to start?I book on-site estimates in the order requests come in.
Pool Removal ·
Great. Where's the project, and how can I reach you?Last step.
Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid 10-digit phone number.
So Mateus can check the property and permits before the visit. Please enter the project address.
Please enter a valid email.

★★★★★ Matt, the owner, came promptly to look at the work and was able to give me a quote on the spot. Varun Varma, Google review

You talk to the owner, not a call center.

Prefer to talk? Call (510) 953-4477
Call Now Get My Price