Licensed & Insured · CA License #1055298 Permits handled for you 5.0 on Google
Home / Pool Removal / Selling With a Filled-In Pool
California · Selling your home

Selling a Home With a Filled-In or Removed Pool in California

By Mateus Lima, owner of Bay Demo, CA License #1055298 · Updated

Quick answer
  • California has no statute written specifically for filled-in pools. What applies is the general seller disclosure law and your city's permit rules.
  • A seller of a one-to-four unit home must give the buyer a written Transfer Disclosure Statement (TDS). The state's standard form has long asked about fill on the property, soil settling and work done without necessary permits.
  • The disclosure duty cannot be waived, must be made in good faith, and is not limited to the items on the form.
  • Keep the paperwork: a closed permit and final inspection, and for a buildable area, an engineer's compaction report.

What California law says about selling with an old pool

QuestionWhat the official source says
Is there a state law just for filled-in pools?We found no California statute written specifically for filling in or removing a residential pool. The seller disclosure law and city permit rules are what apply.
Does the seller have to give a disclosure?Yes, for one-to-four unit homes. The seller delivers the completed written statement to the buyer "as soon as practicable before transfer of title" (Civil Code 1102.3).
What if it arrives after the offer?The buyer has three days after delivery in person, or five days after delivery by mail, to terminate the offer by written notice (Civil Code 1102.3).
Can the buyer and seller agree to skip it?No. "Any waiver of the requirements of this article is void as against public policy" (Civil Code 1102).
What standard applies?Good faith, which the law defines as "honesty in fact in the conduct of the transaction" (Civil Code 1102.7).
Is the form the only duty?No. The list of items on the form "does not limit or abridge any obligation for disclosure created by any other provision of law" (Civil Code 1102.8).
Do expert reports count?The law gives a role to reports from licensed professionals, such as engineers and contractors, on matters within their license (Civil Code 1102.4).

Source: California Civil Code 1102.3 (delivery of the disclosure) (opens the official site) · California Civil Code 1102 (waiver void) (opens the official site) · California Civil Code 1102.7 (good faith) (opens the official site) · California Civil Code 1102.8 (other disclosure duties) (opens the official site) · California Civil Code 1102.4 (reports by licensed experts) (opens the official site) · California Department of Real Estate: Reference Book, Disclosures in a Residential Real Estate Transaction (PDF) (opens the official site)

What the disclosure form asks that touches an old pool

The state's standard Transfer Disclosure Statement has long listed Pool and Spa among the items a property has. In the section on what the seller is aware of, it asks about:

  • Fill (compacted or otherwise) on the property or any portion of it.
  • Any settling, slippage, sliding or other soil problems.
  • Flooding, drainage or grading problems.
  • Room additions, structural changes or other alterations or repairs made without necessary permits, or not in compliance with building codes.

These items come from the Department of Real Estate's reproduction of the form (2005 edition). The form has been updated since, so check the current version with your agent. The form has no question written just for a filled-in pool, but an old pool touches the questions on fill, soil and permits.

The Department of Real Estate's reference book also lists changes "made without required building permits" and "settling or soil problems" among the facts that affect a home's value.

Source: California Department of Real Estate: Disclosures in Real Property Transactions (PDF, 2005 edition, with the TDS form) (opens the official site) · California Department of Real Estate: Reference Book, Disclosures in a Residential Real Estate Transaction (PDF) (opens the official site)

Permitted fill or unpermitted fill: what a buyer sees

A pool that was filled in or removed with a permit leaves a paper trail: the permit, the inspections and the final sign-off. What the record says about the area depends on the method and the city:

  • Partial removal (shell left in place). In Pleasanton (Option 1) and Cupertino (Option A) the area is for landscaping only. Cupertino notes the area may settle.
  • Full removal with engineered fill. Pleasanton (Option 2) and Cupertino (Option B) require an engineer's compaction report at the final, so the area can be built on.
  • Hayward requires an engineer's geotechnical report to build over an old pool, and the report is filed with the property records.
  • Palo Alto requires complete removal of in-ground pools and spas, not abandonment in place.

An unpermitted fill has none of that. It sits right on the questions the form asks about fill, soil settling and work done without permits, and a buyer who plans an ADU or an addition has no report to rely on.

Source: City of Pleasanton: Pool Demolition Requirements (PDF, rev. 01.26) (opens the official site) · City of Cupertino: Swimming Pool Removal Requirements (PDF, 3/2024) (opens the official site) · City of Hayward: Swimming Pool Removal (PDF, created 7-26-18) (opens the official site) · City of Palo Alto: Inspection Guidelines, Pool & Spa Demolition (PDF, rev. 12/20/2018) (opens the official site)

What to keep in your file before you list

  • The permit number and the final inspection record for the pool removal.
  • The method: partial (shell left, landscaping only) or full removal.
  • The engineer's compaction report, if the area was made buildable.
  • Inspection records along the way, such as the drainage-hole inspection some cities require before fill goes in.
  • Utilities: confirmation that the pool's gas and electrical were shut off and capped.
  • The contractor's license number and the written contract.

If a previous owner filled the pool, ask your city's building department whether a pool demolition permit was issued and closed for the address. What to write on the disclosure form is a question for your agent.

This is general information, not legal advice; ask an attorney.

If the pool is still there and you plan to sell

If you remove it before listing, choose the method by who you expect to buy:

  • Buyers who want a yard. A partial removal is the lower-cost path. Our recent written estimates: $10,500 to $11,500, permit included.
  • Buyers who may build. A full removal with engineered fill keeps the area buildable. Our recent written estimates: $19,000 to $21,500, permit included.

Permit review time depends on your city, so we confirm the start date once the permit is approved. We quote both methods on the same visit.

Selling with a filled-in pool: common questions

Do I have to disclose a filled-in pool when selling in California?

There is no California law written just for filled-in pools, but the standard disclosure form asks about fill on the property, soil settling and work done without permits, and the duty to disclose is not limited to the form. Ask your agent or attorney how to word it.

Is a filled-in pool a problem when selling a house?

It depends mostly on the paperwork. A permitted fill with a final inspection is a documented job. An unpermitted fill touches the form's questions on fill, settling and permits.

Can a buyer build where the pool was?

It depends on the city and on how the pool was removed. In Pleasanton and Cupertino, a partial fill-in leaves the area for landscaping and building needs a full removal with an engineer's compaction report; Hayward asks for an engineer's geotechnical investigation and report before you build over a removed pool.

Can the buyer and seller agree to skip the disclosure statement?

No. Civil Code 1102 says any waiver of the disclosure requirements is void as against public policy. Ask your agent whether your sale is covered by the disclosure law.

How do I find out if the previous owner had a permit?

Ask your city's building department whether a pool demolition permit was issued and closed for the address, and ask the seller for the final inspection record and any engineer's report.

Keep reading

Official sources

Mateus Lima, owner of Bay Demo Mateus LimaOwner, Bay Demo · CA Lic. #1055298 5.0 on Google

Step 1 of 2

When do you want to start?
Hi, I'm Mateus. When would you like to start?I book on-site estimates in the order requests come in.
Pool Removal ·
Great. Where's the project, and how can I reach you?Last step.
Please enter your name.
Please enter a valid 10-digit phone number.
So Mateus can check the property and permits before the visit. Please enter the project address.
Please enter a valid email.

★★★★★ Matt, the owner, came promptly to look at the work and was able to give me a quote on the spot. Varun Varma, Google review

You talk to the owner, not a call center.

Prefer to talk? Call (510) 953-4477
Call Now Get My Price